Gambling machines said to be from Tanzania, flood into the country

By Golden Matonga

Across the country, in bars, shops, and gaming rooms, Malawians – especially the young – are fantasizing about getting rich quick. In one of the world’s poorest countries, “slot machines” are spreading like wildfire.

An investigation by the Platform for Investigative Journalism (PIJ) found that at least 90 slot machines have sprung up in Malawi’s Northern Region and parts of Kasungu North.

One of the youngmen captured gambling players at an illegal betting site at Elvak Bar at Bwengu in Rumphi

The PIJ’s investigation also revealed that the gamblers are enriching an illegal betting operation allegedly controlled by Chinese and Tanzanian nationals who are preying on the new craze.

Guided by a source, we went from bar to bar where the machines have been installed. At the Elvak Bar in the market town of Rumphi, for example, we saw bored and jobless youths as young as 15 jamming 100-kwacha tokens into machines in the elusive hope of hitting the jackpot.

The slots are similar to one-armed bandits: players must choose from a selection of animal icons, including buffalo, monkeys, an elephant, and a tiger, which run in a flashing circle until the machine settles on one of them and spits out any winnings.

Slot machines are notoriously addictive and the odds can be easily adjusted to reduce the winnings. In the United States, they account for 70% of casino takings.

There is no agreement on the name of the company operating the machines – some call it Bonanza, others Cisa Malawi.

Neither name appears in the books of the Malawi Gaming Board, which is supposed to license, regulate, and control betting operators in the country. Former board chairperson Billy Banda said they have no record of these companies.

The PIJ’s search for the names at the Registrar General’s office also drew a blank. We could find no evidence that the regulators are supervising the growth of the new industry.

The fact that they are unregulated means that the slots are not tested and verified as offering a fair and reasonably random outcome. As a cash-only business allegedly based across the border in Tanzania, their takings are almost certainly not declared for tax purposes.

Without regulation by entities such as the gaming board and Malawi Bureau of Standards, unsuspecting Malawians could be risking their money on games where the odds are stacked heavily against them.

Locals in the Northern Region claimed that the syndicate behind the machines is run by Chinese and Tanzanian nationals who have been operating in the country for months without a licence.

The company’s operational base in Malawi could not be traced. The Malawi Gaming Board’s former chairperson, Billy Banda, also said they do not have the alleged company names on their books.

Billy Banda, Former chairperson for the Malawi Gaming Board

According to the whistle-blower, who asked not to be named, the company is run by two Chinese nationals identified only as Chen and Haisho, and two Tanzanians, Omega Valentino and a man known only as “Jeffrey”.

Efforts to raise Valentino on his Tanzanian phone number and through his email address proved futile.

Banda said the board would investigate the “totally illegal” operations, but added that its inspections had been suspended due to the Covid-19 pandemic and it was difficult to confiscate equipment.

However, he said the Commissioner of Police “is part of the board, so we will investigate”.

Shortly after the PIJ began asking questions, the authorities pounced on a number of illegal operators, confiscating several machines and arresting two Tanzanian nationals. Their names could not be established, nor whether they have been charged.

Government officials confiscating gambling machines following PIJ Investigations

According to locals, the ring started with a few machines placed in bars in Karonga—a short drive from Mbeya in Tanzania, where the betting syndicate is reportedly based.

It is currently active in Karonga, Rumphi, Mzimba and parts of northern Kasungu. We saw slot machines at Ekwendeni and Enukweni in Mzimba, as well as in Phwezi and Bwengu in Rumphi along the M1 road.

At one of the bars at the Bwengu turn-off that leads to Rumphi, Boma, we gathered information by using the machines and pretending to be interested in investing in the business.

According to an operator we talked to, the slots are loaded with about K4 000 (R95) each day, while making between K10 000 and K20 000 (R238-R476)

He said the equipment is “manipulated” to limit the users’ winnings. The PIJ could not independently confirm this.

“It’s a good business, invest in it,” the smiling operator told us.

He said that since the machine was placed in his bar, neither the gaming board, the Malawi Revenue Authority (MRA) nor police had paid him a visit.

The PIJ’s whistle-blower alleged that the reason the authorities do not bust the ring is that they are paid to look the other way. Banda, the chairperson of the gaming board, said his agency will investigate allegations that his staff is taking bribes.

A source within the syndicate also claimed that the cash illegally generated in Malawi is spirited away to Tanzania.

“They don’t use banks to avoid detection. All the proceeds are being taken into Tanzania,” said a source within the syndicate, raising concerns about money laundering and other financial crimes.

The 2018 Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing National Risk Assessment Report by Malawi’s Financial Intelligence Authority lists gambling as one of the high-risk areas for financial crimes in the country.

The gaming board’s Banda has since called for agencies and stakeholders to work together to deal with the problem.

“We need to collaborate. I’m glad you have exposed this; sometimes we lack the capacity to adequately carry out inspections. The MRA obtains information from the gaming board on the location of companies so that they can collect revenue,” said Banda.

Malawi imposes a gross revenue tax of 12.5 percent on all gaming products.

The legal industry has grown sharply over the past five years, with gross gaming revenue more than doubling to K5.7 billion (R140-million) between 2015 and 2018.

The board’s revenues are also rising, by 15 percent to K917- million (R22-million) between the 2017/18 financial year and 2018/19.

Industry analysts such as United Kingdom-based i-Gaming Business Limited based predict that with the Malawi Gaming Board set to issue more licences for more casinos and sports betting outfits this year, the gross revenue figures from gaming could jump by a factor of 10 or more.

Apart from the social impacts of failing to regulate illegal gambling, the government stands to forfeit both the 12.5 percent cut that the board collects and the tax operators should be paying.

The board invests up to K200-million (R4.8-million) of its revenue in charitable causes, according to its director of social projects and property management, Ted Nandolo.

Ted Nandolo

“Last year we supported communities in Chikwawa that had been devastated by the floods and we helped some households procure iron sheets to rebuild,” Nandolo added.

The board has also used part of its collections from the industry to construct a modern maternity wing at Luwa Health Centre in Rumphi for K100-million (R2.4-million) and a new mortuary at Namitambo Health centre in Thyolo.

Jai Banda, a lawyer, and money laundering expert, also warned about the use of illegal betting to cover illicit transactions and the proceeds of crime.

Jai Banda: Lawyer, and money laundering expert

“The proceeds of crime can be used in betting, and one can claim that such proceeds came through betting,” said Banda.

Betchani Tchereni, an economist based at the University of Malawi, decried the loss of government revenue resulting from inadequate supervision of the gaming industry.

• This story was produced in association with the Platform for Investigative Journalism in Malawi and IJ Hub in South Africa.